
We have seen quite a remarkable feat today in The Hague. Slobodan Milosevic, a man stripped of everything: freedom, dignity, and most importantly, power, has yet again managed to give a metaphorical finger to his enemies in the West.
Make no mistake about it, I am not a Milosevic supporter, but I am hardly a supporter of the Hague Tribunal, either. What jurisdiction, or business, does a court in the Netherlands have trying the former ruler of Serbia? What does the Netherlands have to do with Serbia, other than an upcoming clash in the World Cup? Even the Nazi war criminals were put on trial in their own country. If there was any hope of the outcome of this trial meaning anything to the people of Serbia, it should have taken place in Serbia.
Of course, Milosevic understood this, and played the trial masterfully. He succeeded in making the drawn-out trial more of a liability to the West than an asset. He also understood that the outcome was a foregone conclusion and that he would spend the rest of his life in prison, regardless of how well he defended himself.
So what was Milosevic's goal? To die fighting. As Orwell stated in 1984, it is the goal of every government to avoid, at all costs, creating martyrs out of its enemies. The whole purpose of the trial was to humiliate Milosevic in front of the world's, and more importantly, his supporters' eyes. I personally believe Milosevic has been planning this from the very beginning. First off, he took on an immense workload in insisting that he defend himself at the trial. Second, he was deliberately careless with his health . With his death under the current circumstances, a number of things can be observed:
- years of work by the prosecutors goes down the drain , as the trial is not complete and thus a "true" verdict impossible
- given his relatively good performance at the trial, conspiracy theories surrounding his death were sure to pop up, thus playing well to his nationalist supporters back in Serbia
- Milosevic dies fighting what he considered an illegitimate trial, rather than as a disgraced former leader rotting in a prison cell in the Hague
It is hard to imagine how much better an outcome Milosevic could have hoped for, given that the alternative was a lifetime rotting away in a cell, with his name forgotten and tarnished.
Carla Del Ponte is surely not pleased today.
I have to agree with your analysis of the situation, this will be played up by nationalists for all time in Serbia.
Like that neck of the world really needed another reason to rip itself apart...
It will be interesting to see if this story is another conspiracy theory or not:
Drug traces "found in Milosevic's blood before death" http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/L12781956.htm
One might argue though, that if Milosevic had been allowed to defend his case before a court in Serbia,
it would only have given him "home field advantage" in drawing the case out.
Its already a conspiracy theory.
Apparently he sent his lawyer a letter claiming he was being poisoned.. At least according to the BBC news broadcast that was just on...
One might argue though, that if Milosevic had been allowed to defend his case before a court in Serbia,
it would only have given him "home field advantage" in drawing the case out.
As far as I can tell, that makes no sense.
Nick Ford
As far as I can tell, that makes no sense.
The Hague was chosen as a neutral court because it was felt in part that the courts in
Serbia may have been too biased in favor of acquitting Milosevic (since there are still
factions in the country harboring Ratko Mladic and Radovan Karadzic from similar trials).
Sorry, I misread your original post (not a difficult thing to do, I may add).
I find it somewhat disingenuous to insinuate that the Nuremberg trials had anything to do with German jurisdiction. To my recollection the laws and judicial code used to prosecute the Nazi War Criminals were written by the allies and tailored for these particular defendants.
Certainly the mutual recognition we have of each others jurisdiction does have actual value to us all: it allows us to follow our own social customs with out fear of the laws from foreign regimes. However, what is the value of maintaining jurisdiction when it comes to crimes that happen so rarely and are so universally denounced. While it is entertaining to philosophize about the proper place and way to prosecute Milosevic the reality is his treatment is the same treatment of every ex-leader in his position. That is the treatment that is most convenient and useful for whoever has their mitts on him.
You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead. |